Q-C6.1: Please select the option which is most appropriate for South Warwickshire

Ffurflenni 1 i 30 o 197

ID Ffurflen: 72270

Ymatebydd: Mr Gary Stocker

Option C6.1a: Include a policy that requires new developments to have a whole lifecycle emissions assessment, with a target for 100% reduction in embodied emissions compared to a 'business-as-usual' approach to construction

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Approach a green body representing the building industry as a whole and consult with them. Then discuss with local builders and reach a compromise with an implementation date. Not some vague point in the distant future, but within the near future, such as 2030.

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

With all the talk there has been about it and all the work being done within the field, the building industry should be at least half prepared for this as a likelihood. Starting with a clean slate and building net zero carbon buildings and not need any future retrofitting is an ideal way forward: prevention is better than cure.

ID Ffurflen: 72341

Ymatebydd: Mr Robert Sherman

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

80% by 2030 and 100% by 2040

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Developers have not shown themselves keen to address this issue, so specific targets will have to be employed. However, these alone won't be enough unless there are clear penalties for failing to meet those requirements.

ID Ffurflen: 72373

Ymatebydd: Mr John Greenshields

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Reducing emissions and focussing on Net Zero is important. However this should never become disproportionate (a large minimum threshold should be set) nor bar the delivery of much needed development.

ID Ffurflen: 72409

Ymatebydd: Mr Stuart Boyle

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Setting a date encourages developers to build ahead of that date so the number of properties that the new policy applies to is reduced. New policies should ideally be applied immediately. If phased in then the phasing should be linked to the number of properties rather than a date so it would not apply to the first X properties build but would apply to any subsequent properties.

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Where possible developments should prepare for retrofitting of renewable technology. E.g. new build should have a clear east, south or west facing roof suitable for solar panels. Heating should be under-floor rather than radiator with minimum pipe bore sizes suitable for heat pumps. Roof and drive drainage should not flow into sewer systems.

ID Ffurflen: 72483

Ymatebydd: Mr Roger Lloyd

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Net Carbon zero is required, but should be applied with sensitivety to historic buildings.

ID Ffurflen: 72886

Ymatebydd: Mr Darrell Muffitt

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 73038

Ymatebydd: Mrs Laura Gibb

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Don’t know why this isn’t already happening? The climate crisis has been obvious for decades.

ID Ffurflen: 73112

Ymatebydd: Mrs alexandra glackin

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 73288

Ymatebydd: Mr CHRIS DAVIS

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

I don't have the expertise to offer a view

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 73360

Ymatebydd: Mr Michael Palmer-Gee

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 73433

Ymatebydd: Mrs victoria Palmer-Gee

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 73434

Ymatebydd: Mr Michael Palmer-Gee

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 73539

Ymatebydd: Mrs Clare Forrest

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 73594

Ymatebydd: Mr michael dufty

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

UNABLE TO AFVISE

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 73728

Ymatebydd: Coventry Airport Ltd

Asiant : Mr Robert Barnes

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 73766

Ymatebydd: DR Angela Quartermaine Carr

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Tough question! This would need analysis by experts

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 73907

Ymatebydd: Mr Joshua Niderost

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 73933

Ymatebydd: Mrs Anna Corser

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 74237

Ymatebydd: Mr James Dex

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Where retrofitting becomes not financially viable, it does become viable when no other sites i.e Greenbelt are available for developers. These are exactly the sites that need retrofitting and turning into housing stock. Where appropriate incentives need to be given.

ID Ffurflen: 74370

Ymatebydd: Dr Martin Randall

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 74475

Ymatebydd: Mrs Margaret dufty

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

THIS POLICY MUST BE CAREFULLY PHASED IN

ID Ffurflen: 74616

Ymatebydd: Mrs Sidney Syson

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 74661

Ymatebydd: Mrs Emma Stolwood

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

We need to make these changes ASAP

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 74697

Ymatebydd: St Modwen Developments Ltd and Jeremy A Clay, Suzanne D Wyatt (as trustee), Suzanne D Wyatt, Emma PJ Defries, James PC Sandbach

Asiant : Mr Robert Barnes

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 74826

Ymatebydd: Mr Richard Thomas

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 74931

Ymatebydd: Forward Group

Asiant : Mr Nigel McGurk

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 75201

Ymatebydd: mr william tansey

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 75270

Ymatebydd: Shipston on Stour Town Council

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

In the future, such buildings must not be allowed to detract from the external visual impact which must be given equal consideration. (For example white warehouses in sensitive rural locations.)

ID Ffurflen: 75548

Ymatebydd: Dr Malcolm Strens

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 75753

Ymatebydd: Mr Chris King

dewiswyd

Option C6.1b: Include a policy that has different whole lifecycle reduction targets for different scales and types of developments and for different time periods

dewiswyd

Option C6.1c: None of these

dewiswyd

Q-C6.2: If a phased approach is used, what dates and thresholds should be used?

Ni roddwyd ateb

Q-C6.3: Please add any comments you wish to make about Net Zero Carbon buildings in South Warwickshire

The plan needs a policy requiring that all retrofit should be undertaken to a specific standard. The reason for this is that the current supply chain o in the market can be likened to the ‘wild west’. If deep retrofit is not done properly the health and wellbeing of occupants and indeed building fabric will suffer. The following is a list of appropriate standards: PAS 2035 for domestic buildings PAS 2038 for non-domestic buildings EnerPHit Standards – this is retrofit using the Passivhaus Standard Energiesprong – this would be useful for council homes and social housing. AECB or LETI - Retrofit Standard for housing. Include an intention to encourage development of solar panels and/or affordable housing above large private as well as public carparks eg supermarkets treating them as quasi brownfield.