BASE HEADER

Q-D1.1: Do you agree that this is an appropriate range of topics for a strategic design policy?

Ffurflenni 61 i 90 o 111
ID Ffurflen: 78864
Ymatebydd: Mr Steven Simpson

Yes

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 78868
Ymatebydd: Mr Alan Roberts

No

New developments are led by developers profits, independent planners/ designers should propose what is best to be built.

ID Ffurflen: 78871
Ymatebydd: Mr Tim Barr

No

Under section 8 of the NPPF (Promoting healthy and safe communities) it says "93. To provide the social, recreational and cultural facilities and services the community needs, planning policies and decisions should: a) plan positively for the provision and use of shared spaces, community facilities (such as local shops, meeting places, sports venues, open space, cultural buildings, public houses and places of worship) and other local services to enhance the sustainability of communities and residential environments". This needs to be included in strategic design principles to ensure developments are promoting such communities from the conceptual stage of a development.

ID Ffurflen: 79036
Ymatebydd: Elizabeth White

Don't know

Must be equitably applied: DS15 Comprehensive Development of Strategic Sites - H03 not included! Development brief for W/20/0617;W/21/0590;W/22/0232?

ID Ffurflen: 79091
Ymatebydd: Barford, Sherbourne and Wasperton Joint Parish Council

Yes

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 79709
Ymatebydd: IM Land
Asiant : Turley

Yes

3.40 IM generally agree that the range of topics set out is appropriate for a strategic design policy. It is important to consider that a ‘well-designed place’ refers to the place as a whole, and should therefore include built form but also landscaping and planting.

ID Ffurflen: 79751
Ymatebydd: Taylor Wimpey
Asiant : Turley

Dim byd wedi’i ddewis

3.69 High quality design should be at the heart of new development in the SWLP, with welldesigned places considering of a range of key factors, contributed to by the place and surrounding environment as a whole. This includes the built form, but also effective and valuable green infrastructure and landscaping, which should be particularly emphasised when considering sites to release from the Green Belt.

ID Ffurflen: 80169
Ymatebydd: Sport England

No

Sport England would encourage that the Design Policy should embed the principles set out Sport England’s Active Design Guidance, which is all about the how the design of our environment can help people to lead more physically active and healthy lifestyles. In helping to create an ‘Active Environment’ whereby spaces and places encourage an environment for people to be active. The environments should not just be focussed on delivering opportunities for sport and formal exercise. Instead, they seek to encourage physical activity – such as walking, cycling, sport, exercise, children’s play, outdoor leisure and anything else that maximises opportunities for people to be active. Physical activity can also improve mental health of adults and children. Where we live, work, travel and play have a major role in shaping our activity choices. By following Active Design principles in the design of our built environments, we can create Active Environments that will encourage people to be active through their everyday lives.

ID Ffurflen: 80775
Ymatebydd: Natural England

Dim byd wedi’i ddewis

Issue D1: Strategic design principles: There are a good range of topics included here however, environmental sustainability is a term broadly applied to a range of areas. However, a key building block includes the role that biodiversity plays within the sustainability of our natural world. Thus Natural England feels that it should be specifically mentioned as a separate but connected topic that acts as a golden thread.

ID Ffurflen: 80933
Ymatebydd: Tanworth Residents Association

Yes

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 81002
Ymatebydd: Taylor Wimpey (Midlands) Ltd and Bloor Homes
Asiant : Cerda Planning

Yes

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 81051
Ymatebydd: Taylor Wimpey (Midlands) Ltd and Bloor Homes
Asiant : Cerda Planning

Yes

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 81130
Ymatebydd: James Bushell
Asiant : Framptons

Yes

Option D2c is considered to be the most appropriate for South Warwickshire.

ID Ffurflen: 81216
Ymatebydd: Crest Nicholson
Asiant : Savills

No

Any policy setting out strategic design principles should also include reference to deliverability and viability and how design choices need to be weighed up against these two key issues.

ID Ffurflen: 81433
Ymatebydd: Bellway Strategic Land
Asiant : Savills

No

No - Comprehensive development is listed as one of the key strategy design principles on page 138. Bellway considers that the approach to comprehensive development needs to be flexible and not hold the delivery of sites back should all landowners not be fully engaged.

ID Ffurflen: 81526
Ymatebydd: Spitfire Homes
Asiant : Harris Lamb

Yes

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 81564
Ymatebydd: Catesby Estates Ltd
Asiant : Stantec UK Limited t/a Barton Willmore

Dim byd wedi’i ddewis

6.1 Design is not a strategic issue and should therefore be addressed within the respective Part 2 Plans. 6.2 The topics for a strategic design policy should be based upon those identified within Paragraph 130 of the NPPF. The principles set out are acceptable as worded, however further clarity should be made to provide greater detail of the requirements of each topic. Therefore, the principle of the topics are acceptable, however the detail associated with each topic needs to be considered and engaged upon further.

ID Ffurflen: 81686
Ymatebydd: Vistry Partnerships
Asiant : Harris Lamb

Yes

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 81716
Ymatebydd: Mars Pension Trustees
Asiant : Harris Lamb

Yes

Yes, the range of topics identified is appropriate for a strategic design policy. South Warwickshire has a large plan area, comprising large towns, a variety of villages of different size, hamlets and significant areas of countryside. It is, therefore, imperative that a design policy is flexible to recognise the different environments across the plan area, delivering high quality schemes.

ID Ffurflen: 81878
Ymatebydd: IM Land and IM Properties
Asiant : Turley

Yes

IM Land generally agree that the range of topics set out is appropriate for a strategic design policy. It is important to consider that a ‘well-designed place’ refers to the place as a whole, and should therefore include built form but also landscaping and planting.

ID Ffurflen: 82104
Ymatebydd: The Kler Group
Asiant : Cerda Planning Ltd

Yes

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 82209
Ymatebydd: Cerda Planning Ltd

Yes

Ni roddwyd ateb

ID Ffurflen: 82613
Ymatebydd: Barratt David Wilson Homes (Mercia)
Asiant : Harris Lamb

Yes

Yes, the range of topics identified is appropriate for a strategic design policy. South Warwickshire has a large plan area, comprising large towns, a variety of villages of different size, hamlets and significant areas of countryside. It is, therefore, imperative that a design policy is flexible to recognise the different environments across the plan area, delivering high quality schemes.

ID Ffurflen: 82677
Ymatebydd: Stratford Town Centre Strategic Partnership

Yes

Yes but these may not be the only ones required

ID Ffurflen: 82935
Ymatebydd: Richborough Estates
Asiant : Star Planning and Development

Dim byd wedi’i ddewis

50. Any policy concerning design needs to be proportionate to the scale of the development proposed. It would be reasonable for the Local Plan to include a comprehensive strategic design policy for large scale proposals but such a policy would not be as effective for house extensions.

ID Ffurflen: 82984
Ymatebydd: Richborough Estates
Asiant : Star Planning and Development

Dim byd wedi’i ddewis

52. Any policy concerning design needs to be proportionate to the scale of the development proposed. It would be reasonable for the Local Plan to include a comprehensive strategic design policy for large scale proposals but such a policy would not be as effective for house extensions.

ID Ffurflen: 83014
Ymatebydd: Richborough Estates
Asiant : Star Planning and Development

Dim byd wedi’i ddewis

52. Any policy concerning design needs to be proportionate to the scale of the development proposed. It would be reasonable for the Local Plan to include a comprehensive strategic design policy for large scale proposals but such a policy would not be as effective for house extensions.

ID Ffurflen: 83044
Ymatebydd: Richborough Estates
Asiant : Star Planning and Development

Dim byd wedi’i ddewis

Q-D1.1 49. Any policy concerning design needs to be proportionate to the scale of the development proposed. It would be reasonable for the Local Plan to include a comprehensive strategic design policy for large scale proposals but such a policy would not be as effective for house extensions.

ID Ffurflen: 83075
Ymatebydd: Richborough Estates
Asiant : Star Planning and Development

Dim byd wedi’i ddewis

Q-D1.1 50. Any policy concerning design needs to be proportionate to the scale of the development proposed. It would be reasonable for the Local Plan to include a comprehensive strategic design policy for large scale proposals but such a policy would not be as effective for house extensions.

ID Ffurflen: 83092
Ymatebydd: Beaudesert & Henley in Arden Joint Parish Council

Dim byd wedi’i ddewis

The JPC strongly endorses proposals to protect and enhance the historic and environmental quality of the town and the steps to be taken by the partnership to achieve that. This level of proposal, however, appears to JPC to be far too detailed and is an example of excessive scope/detail in the consultation. These are all issues that are being delegated to NPs and there needs to be some reference in the document to encouraging Neighbourhood Plans to undertake this activity and guidance as to appropriate approaches.