BASE HEADER

RDS1: The Council is adopting an Interim Level of Growth of 12,300 homes between 2011 and 2029

Yn dangos sylwadau a ffurflenni 91 i 120 o 331

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 54988

Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013

Ymatebydd: mr Robert Ellis

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

* dispute the need for over 12,000 houses in the local area as independent evidence suggests that local needs are half this number.

* It is wrong to forecast up to 2029 and allocate green land now. It is akin to having no plan at all, allowing developers to uncontrolled growth, just leaving developers to decide what to build and when.

* This plan is not about meeting local housing requirements but is designed to attract thousands of extra residents into an area where there is not enough work for them or the infrastructure to support the numbers.

* Stratford District Council have announced plans to build close to Gaydon which will provide homes for workers at Jaguar/ Landrover which was part of Warwick's plan, so we already have a double count on housing needs.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 54992

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Mr Peter Cunningham

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The number of houses is too high. Projected population growth in the area does not demand it and takes no account of other developments, such as at Gaydon, and the pressures that this will place on Warwick and Leamington infrastructure.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 54995

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Mr Peter Lamb

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

There is no rational reason for planning so high a number of new homes as 12,300 at the present time.

Understand that the actual needs of the local people over the 15-year time period have been calculated as around 5,300 homes - much less than half of that figure.

There is presently no housing shortage and no demand for additional business premises, as is demonstrated by planned business developments that have not come to fruition and by, for example, the number of vacant premises on the Technology Park and other business sites in the area.

Such a quantity of extra housing would depress prices and attract incoming population, not for any reason that would have an economic advantage to the area, but simply because Warwick has the advantage of being a pleasant place to live.

It has been increasingly obvious that the town's infrastructure simply cannot support such a large increase in population and some of the issues it would raise have no clear solution, as will be noted below.

Whereas the housing demand may change in the future, a 15-year forecast, from any current projection, is unlikely to be realistic.

Similar forecasts made in 1998 for a period of time up to the present day would have been hopelessly wrong due to the unforeseeable degree of intervening economic and social changes.

There is no reason to believe that today's estimates will be any more reliable.

There is ample time, over the next decade, to make any adjustments that might prove necessary should an actual demand, from either the housing or the business sector, manifest itself.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55000

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Mrs & Mr Claire & Philip Harris

Nifer y bobl: 2

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The proposal for 12,000 new houses far exceeds local need.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55003

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Mrs Larraine Curzon

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Fully aware that some additional housing in the Leamington/Warwick area is needed and accept that the area south of Leamington should take a share of this development. However, the level of proposed development south of the town and the majority of it on agricultural land is excessive. The local need was for 6000 new houses by c. 2030; why has the District Council now proposed 12000?

Where this demand is coming from? 4,000 + houses south of Leamington will attract many people currently living and working in Birmingham and other commutable distances so it is not for the benefit of local people and encouraging more car use seems very out of kilter with sustainable development.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55004

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: dr eirian curzon

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

* The housing numbers are excessively high, the RDS proposes 12000 new houses by 2030 whereas the local need is for fewer than 6000. Projections, based from the last 2011 census, by Ray Bullen (Parish cllr. Bishop's Tachbrook) show only a need for 5400, and the WDC own consultants (G. L. Hearn) for the Economic and Demographic Forecast Survey of December 2012 estimated only 4405.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55006

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Mr & Mrs Brian & Beryl Bate

Nifer y bobl: 2

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The NPPF requires sustainable development which meets an established housing need.

Local developers already have around 5000 homes in the pipe line and are not developing them. 12300 new homes easily exceeds the demand for this area and would mean that even more Greenfield land would be lost to the local agricultural businesses.

Understand that there are currently around 5000 unoccupied homes in the district that could be taken over, refurbished and returned to the housing market.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55007

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Miss J Hornsby

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The 12,300 is the latest number that is now being quoted by WDC. This has been challenged as being pure guesswork without any positive proof. It has been suggested that 5,400 is closer to the truth following work by a local councillor.

The laws of supply and demand should be accepted as being the meter for providing houses for those who not only need them but can afford them. The 12,300 number being quoted by WDC is a mythical number with no proof. Therefore the New Local Plan should have recognised this fact and factored the numbers accordingly

A further proof of supply and demand is that the estate agents are overflowing with houses for sale, but only a few that are affordable.

Another fact is that present house owners wishing to move or upsize cannot afford to due to the squeeze from government spending cuts. Their only answer is to extend and even that is very restricted due to the high costs involved and petty restrictions imposed by District Councils.

(forms part of rep on planning application W13/0036)

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55020

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Richard Staff

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The projected housing requirment of 12,300 new homes to be built seems much too high, with less than half that number needed to meet local needs. Without having sufficient employment opportunities for an increased population, it seems highly inappropriate to allocate greenfield land now for housing that is not required by the local population. There are sufficient brownfield sites in Warwick (and immediate environs) to meet the projected local housing need

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55021

Derbyniwyd: 16/07/2013

Ymatebydd: warwick books ltd

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

* Do we really need 12,000 houses? Affordable homes we probably do need, but not on this scale.

* Are the proposed new builds all aimed at the lower end of the market? Probably not.

* Looking at the local estate agents there is indeed no shortage of houses in the mid- to upper-price range, so why build more?

* Why pay consultants to establish that the local need will be for less than 6,000 new homes if their findings are to be totally ignored?

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55027

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Christine Burke

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The 12,300 is the latest number that is now being quoted by WDC. This has been challenged as being pure guesswork without any positive proof. It has been suggested that 5,400 is closer to the truth following work by a local councillor

(from objection to planning app ref: W13/0607)

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55030

Derbyniwyd: 16/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Mr Andrew Copson

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

It has been clearly established that the local need is for fewer than 6000 new houses by about 2030, however the Local Plan proposed more than 12000.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55035

Derbyniwyd: 16/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Mrs Jan Copson

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

It has been clearly established that the local need is for fewer than 6000 new houses by about 2030, however the Local Plan proposed more than 12000.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55037

Derbyniwyd: 16/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Mr Mark Edwards

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The local need is for fewer than 6,000 new houses by about 2030. But the District Council proposes more than 12,000. 4,500 of them are south of Warwick.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55051

Derbyniwyd: 16/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Mr Paul Dawson

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Too many houses are proposed and will lead to further traffic congestion. It is not reasonable to build such a larger extension to a small town like Warwick

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55057

Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Joan Livingstone

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

A plan that will allow for balanced growth and growth that is compatible with, and responds to, local needs is surely all that is required.

Why is there a need for more than that?

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55059

Derbyniwyd: 16/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Mr & Mrs Simon & Sukwant Drake

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The numbers of houses planned are way in excess of estimated demand - this appears to be on the same principles of the mass proposed building in Stratford-upon-Avon - a case of "people want to live here, so let's build here rather than somewhere that has the infrastructure and ability to support such an influx of homes and people". The Plan does not seem sensible in line with the needs and rights of current, or indeed future, residents of Warwick and its surrounding area.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55078

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Sharon Jennings

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The local need for housing is 6,000 new homes by 2030, why is it proposed that 12,000 new homes be built?
Understanding that using projections based on natural growth of the population with an allowance for migration this would mean a total of 5,400 homes would be required. This information was taken from a paper prepared by Ray Bullen in July 2012 that was updated using 2011 census data in 2013.

Also understand that Council's own consultants, GL Hearn, gave an Economic and Demographic Forecast study in December 2012 in which they arrived at a figure of 4405 houses required.

Warwick District has a low unemployment level of 1.7% and so increasing the housing to meet job needs is not an issue.

The 2012 Strategic Housing Market Assessment said that overall "Warwick District had a very good jobs-homes balance.

Why is the local plan proposing more than twice the amount of homes identified as being required?

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55088

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Mr & Mrs Brian & Thelma Malin

Nifer y bobl: 2

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

It is likely that according to a recent study that the need for new housing in the district is less than 6000 rather than the grossly inflated figure of 12000 new homes as proposed by the Council.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55090

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Bernice Johnson

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

12,300 homes seems very extreme. Projections (based on 2011 Census data in 2013) seem to suggest that around 5,400 homes would be needed in the area, allowing for migration and natural growth of the population. The Council's own Economic and Demographic Forecast Study in December 2012 stated 4,405 new homes were needed.
These figures indicate the housing figure in the Local Plan is more than double what is actually needed.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55094

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Helen Johnson

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

12, 300 homes seems very extreme. Projections (based on 2011 Census data in 2013) seem to suggest that around 5,400 homes would be needed in the area, allowing for migration and natural growth of the population. The Council's own Economic and Demographic Forecast Study in December 2012 stated 4,405 new homes were needed.
These figures indicate the housing figures in the Local Plan is more than double what is actually needed.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55096

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Mark Johnson

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

12, 300 homes seems very extreme. Projections (based on 2011 Census data in 2013) seem to suggest that around 5,400 homes would be needed in the area, allowing for migration and natural growth of the population. The Council's own Economic and Demographic Forecast Study in December 2012 stated 4,405 new homes were needed.
These figures indicate the housing figures in the Local Plan is more than double what is actually needed.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55131

Derbyniwyd: 24/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Nuneaton & Bedworth Borough Council

Asiant : Nuneaton & Bedworth Borough Council

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

A joint Strategic Housing Market Assessment is being prepared to guide the setting of housing provision figures for the relevant Councils. This approach is appropriate in terms of ensuring that Warwick's Local Plan meets the full objectively assessed needs for housing in the housing market area. As yet, this work is not complete and so it is not possible to comment on whether or not the proposed figure of 12,300 will meet the needs for housing.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55143

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Carroll Petit

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

RDS is unsustainable. Too many new house proposed as there are already thousands of empty houses in the area around Warwick which could be improved and sold on. Suggest it might be better to halve the number of houses, renovate the thousands of empty ones and to place some of the remaining half equally distributed north, south, east and west around the area.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55145

Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013

Ymatebydd: mr Julian Richards

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The sheer number of homes which the plan provides for is excessive. The claim that we need over 12,000 new homes is in direct contrast with the assessments of projected local need which claim we need only around 5,000 new homes to meet the local needs. The additional homes will only create an influx of people who will live in Warwick because there are homes here but then commute to Birmingham or Coventry for work, bringing Warwick itself nothing but strain on its infrastructure and increased traffic and air pollution. The SHLAA indicates the districts maximum capacity for expansion by 2029 is a little over 13,000 homes, meaning that the local plan would use up more than 90% of this capacity with homes which we do not need and would force any further expansion to come at the expense of the local environment to a greater extent even than the current plan does.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55176

Derbyniwyd: 21/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Jenny Bevan

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Suggest 12,300 figures are inaccurate and agree with Bishop's Tachbrook PC that only 5,400 needed for natural growth and migration. Warwick District Council's own consultants G.L. Hearn gave an Economic and Demographic Forecast Study projection of 4,405 and given low unemployment rate, growth for employment is not a valid argument to explain higher figures. Local environment would undoubtedly be negatively impacted by future developments.

Local Development Framework, Annual Monitoring Report 2011, noted that high rate of housebuilding is fuelling immigration to the district. Therefore large scale development will exacerbate not solve the local housing issues and is unsustainable.

Serious concerns any proposed infrastructure improvements given recent poor project management with High Street/Jury Street roadworks and the Morrisons development roadworks. During any upgrades strain on local infrastructure will be intolerable and considerable inconvenience placed on local residents and businesses.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55177

Derbyniwyd: 21/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Mr Adrian Bevan

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Suggest 12,300 figures are inaccurate and agree with Bishop's Tachbrook PC that only 5,400 needed for natural growth and migration. Warwick District Council's own consultants G.L. Hearn gave an Economic and Demographic Forecast Study projection of 4,405 and given low unemployment rate, growth for employment is not a valid argument to explain higher figures. Local environment would undoubtedly be negatively impacted by future developments.

Local Development Framework, Annual Monitoring Report 2011, noted that high rate of housebuilding is fuelling immigration to the district. Therefore large scale development will exacerbate not solve the local housing issues and is unsustainable.

Serious concerns any proposed infrastructure improvements given recent poor project management with High Street/Jury Street roadworks and the Morrisons development roadworks. During any upgrades strain on local infrastructure will be intolerable and considerable inconvenience placed on local residents and businesses.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55189

Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Brian Logan

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The local need for housing is 6,000 new homes by 2030, why is it proposed that 12,000 new homes be built?
Understand that using projections based on natural growth of the population with an allowance for migration this would mean a total of 5,400 homes would be required. This information was taken from a paper prepared by Ray Bullen in July 2012 that was updated using 2011 census data in 2013.

Also understand that Council's own consultants, GL Hearn, gave an Economic and Demographic Forecast study in December 2012 in which they arrived at a figure of 4405 houses required.

Why is the local plan proposing more than twice the amount of homes identified as being required?

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55193

Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Mr S Bazin

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The size of Warwick has increased by 1% a year over the last 10 years, double the rate of growth for Warwickshire as a whole and double the national average. Surely it's now time to look elsewhere. Need to reduce this to help to assimilate the new houses already built (and still being built) within the current structure.

The planned development in Warwick and Leamington appears to be designed to meet a target for the wider area, including for example the Stratford on Avon, whilst totally ignoring significant development proposed in that neighbouring town, including the controversial Shottery development for 800 houses already approved in that area, to name but one.

The proposals for the whole area are designed, not just as an organic growth to satisfy local demand of around 5,000 homes which could be satisfied by development on existing brown-field sites, but apparently to bring in from far and wide new residents to the area which will have the net effect of turning our lovely ancient market town, an attraction to British and Overseas tourists, into an ugly dormitory for the major conurbations of Birmingham and Coventry.

Gwrthwynebu

Revised Development Strategy

ID sylw: 55200

Derbyniwyd: 21/07/2013

Ymatebydd: Whitnash Residents Association

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Understand the need for some growth, but do not agree with the level of growth proposed. Do not feel there is a need for the large amount of homes planned for and believe half the number will serve to provide for our residents.