BASE HEADER
GT06 Land at Park Farm, Spinney Farm
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56294
Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Chris Hastie
Appears to have nothing to recommend it in terms of access to facilities. The level of isolation of the sites is also unlikely to promote inclusion.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56331
Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013
Ymatebydd: D J & S K Waite
Nifer y bobl: 2
Appreciate the council is obliged to provide permanent pitches but the site is unsuitable, especially as it is very remote.
Bishops Tachbrook has very few resources (a church, a small grocers shop, a hairdressers, a sports and social club, a small primary school and mobile library and a mobile chip shop on occasions.) Accordingly most locals commute outside of the village to work so where would the gypsy and travelling community find work locally? The site would be an undue strain on local resources.
The school is at capacity and relies on parents to help. Who will provide the extra support that will be needed for additional children, especially as illiteracy rates are high in the adult gypsy and traveller communities so they cannot help? Local Secondary schools are also over subscribed.
The local doctor's surgery is very small and very busy. Additional families would put the surgery under undue pressure.
The cost to connect sewage, water, electricity or gas to the site will be huge and existing services are not of sufficient size to take the extra load.
These plans would deter the bats from their natural habitat, near the fields at the top of the village
There is also a very limited public transport option with no adequate bus stops or path to walk anywhere and cycling is dangerous on busy commuter routes.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56359
Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Sprue Safety Products Ltd
Appreciate Council are under instruction to provide sites but objection to this option as its in the wrong area:
Existing education and health standards in the Gypsy and Traveller community could put a major strain on the already overworked facilities in the area.
St Josephs' Primary in Whitnash is oversubscribed. Illiteracy levels in Gypsy and Traveller parents means they are not in a position to help children with their own learning placing greater pressure on resources. The children will struggle to integrate into the local school environment. Will the council supply additional funds to help expand/support facilities? Will catchment areas have to change?
Limited employment opportunities in the local economy for Gypsies and Travellers, especially if they are illiterate.
Limited facilities in Bishops Tachbrook. Would be interested to see the evidence to show how a Gypsy and Traveller site can support local sustainability in this area.
Surely Bishops Tachbrook is too remote from the main infrastructure of Leamington Spa or Warwick to be suitable for this type of development?
Will it have an impact on tourism in the area?
Fail to see how Gypsies and Travellers could contribute to this small community.
Site is prone to flooding.
No adequate provision of utilities such as sewerage, drainage, gas and water. Who pays for it?
On a very major road but not on a bus route and with no means of pedestrian access.
Borders the M40 so will be very noisy for site occupants.
Very remote from main centres and no means of pedestrian access
Currently working farm land and home to many forms of farm and wildlife animals.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56467
Derbyniwyd: 22/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Mr Adrian Bevan
Site would put undue pressure on a busy GP surgery.
The primary school is already at capacity.
The Gypsy and Traveller community are more likely to need specialist educational needs which the school cannot cater for.
Public transport is limited within the parish with no pavements joing the sites - pedestrian access would be dangerous.
It is not possible to make safe access to the road network, surrounded on three sides by busy roads, the traffic noise from this would be detrimental to the residents' well-being.
Provision of utilities is limited.
Both the A425 and the A452 run alongside this site. This means the potential visual impact on the approach to historic Warwick is doubled as visitors leaving the motorway both northbound and southbound would see the site as they enter Warwick.
Tourism in Warwick is very important to the local economy and any impact would severely damage the town. It is close to Castle Park which is an important historical area of Warwick.
There is very strong local opposition to the site - it would not promote a peaceful and integrated co-exitence.
The A452 and A425 are busy and dangerous roads. There are few local services nearby so those that do exist are likely to be put under undue pressure.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56491
Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Georgina Farndon
No convenient access to a GP surgery, school and public transport;
Unsafe access to a very fast and busy road network. dangerous for pedestrian access into Warwick until the pavement starts at the junction with Barford Hill.
Adverse impact on the landscape and character of the area into Warwick.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56518
Derbyniwyd: 01/09/2013
Ymatebydd: Mr Ray Steele
The site does not meet the Council's site requirements and therefore does not address the Issues affecting the Gypsy and Traveller community. In general, the site is remote from amenities and would place unreasonable pressure on local infrastructure and services. The proximity of major roads and existing communities to the site will create potential for noise and disturbance.
The proposed location cannot be integrated into the landscape without harming the character of the area. The potential visual impact on the approach to Warwick will damage tourist Industry and the local economy.
Businesses within the Bishop's Tachbrook Area may also suffer; Listed Buildings in Bishop's Tachbrook may be subject to possible damage; if the site is used as a place of work, there is a threat of pollution to the Tachbrook Brook; loss of good quality arable land. Overall there will be an adverse impact on important features of the natural and historic environment.
Bishop's Tachbrook Primary School & Nursery are oversubscribed. Providing the additional support required by Gypsy and Traveller children will be difficult to provide without adversely impacting all pupils without additional funding from the County Council.
Site access directly on to roads within 50 mph speeds doesn't enable safe access to the road network, especially if large caravans are turning. There are no pedestrian footpaths or public transport links. School children will have to wait for school buses on main roads or be transported to safe bus stops by car or all the way to school. This is not a sustainable solution.
The provision of utilities on the sites is questionable.
Where will the Gypsy & Traveller Community find work?
The site is likely to be operated by the Gypsy Community and not the Council so the actual numbers of people on site won't be regulated or controlled.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56620
Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Mr Nicholas Rutter
Site has no pavement pedestrian access to any local facilities. Seen wild deer on the site on numerous occasions.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56640
Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Sharon Jennings
Suggests Bishops Tachbrook is being penalised for having a part time GP surgery. Explains difficulties of obtaining appointments and questions impact of 6 G & T sites in the vicinity noting the known health problems and mortality rates of G & Ts and potential strain on medical facilities. There is no dentist. Questions if sites too remote from infrastructure of Lemington Spa or Warwick. Effect on Bishops Tachbrook would be devastating to way of life; not a reasonable request. If GT05, GT06, GT09 and GT10 permitted will mean huge encampment in a small area. Community already stretched to capacity and fail to see how G & T will contribute.
Also refers to education statistics and potential strain on education facilities referring to the Catholic primary school already turning siblings away. Where parents are not literate will add pressure. Lack of literacy also affects employment opportunities and contribution to schools. Bishops Tachbrook school is single form entry. Small school unlikely to be able to provide required infrastructure and resources. Children will struggle to integrate. Questions if a new school will be built which will affect catchment areas and unfair to existing residents.
Secondary schools also oversubscribed.
Site is prone to flooding.
Questions provision of utilities; sewerage, drainage, gas and water are inadequate. Remote from main centres.
Site on fast moving main road with no means of pedestrian access, footways or bus routes.
Borders M40 therefore noisy for occupants.
Home to farm and wildlife and working farm land.
Would harm character of area and not integrate.
Highly unlikely to be peaceful and integrated co-existence given level of local disagreement.
Questions evidence of how G & T site supports local sustainability.
Limited public transport options.
Questions need for proposed numbers given Salford University findings.
Questions site management over e.g. noise, pollution and overcrowding and control of population numbers and expansion.
Questions effect on house prices.
Sites remote from employment and facilities and unsuitable.
No statement of need from a Gypsy body; question desire or evidence of such. Lack of meaningful data; therefore question validity of study.
GTAA shows need for 31 yet brochure shows only 19 - need for clarity over future. Map not accurate representation.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56676
Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Raza Shah
Extremely remote from main centers.
No pedestrian access.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56713
Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Barford Residents Association
Extensive area of land exceeds what is needed, therefore assume intend max 15 pitches.
Site is unsuitable, undeliverable and undevelopable. Landowner unwilling to sell or develop.
No convenient access to GP surgery, school and public transport.
Safe access not possible and no evidence can be provided. Heavily used road with slow moving vehicles giving unsafe situation.
Noise and disturbance from A452 and Warwick bypass.
No utilities.
No ecology or biodiversity evidence. Contend unacceptable harm. Therefore contrary to policy.
Greenfield not capable of successful integration into landscape without material harm to character.
Former landfill site with potential for gas; therefore unsuitable for occupation.
Site adjacent to The Asps; decision to remain open due to landscape and transport impact of development as backdrop to Warwick Castle Park. This site has same value.
Does not accord with Planning Policy for Traveller Sites; does not promote peaceful integrated co-existence or avoid undue pressure on infrastructure and services
Urge no further consideration.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56729
Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Ms Miriam Bannon
Extremely remote form main centers.
No pedestrian access.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56753
Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Mr Christopher Ainslie
Site has no local amenities: no schools or GP surgeries within 1.5 miles; no bus stops within a mile of the site. Would place additional pressure on Barford School.
Site access problematic as roads bordering the site have 60 mph speed limits and Brrford Road is an accident blackspot according to WCC records and it is very straight road which encourages speed.
Proximity to busy roads and M40 plus south westerly winds makes site noisy for any residents.
Telephone mast in north eastern corner, which is classed by WHO and International Agency for Research on Cancer as a mobile radiation source so not recommended for residential area.
No utilities (gas, water, sewerage) which would have to be purpose built.
Boarders Warwick Castle Park so threatens archaeological and ecological points of interest. Conservation bodies will want to protect the park at all costs.
Cannot be integrated into landscape as its farmland so very visible. This would impact on the town's tourism.
Site has no amenities and in the middle of a field, which is a former landfill site, so cannot promote peaceful and integrated co-existence.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56769
Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Bob McNamara
Very remote from major amenities and main centres.
On very major road with no pedestrian access.
Undue pressure on infrastructure and services. Bishops Tachbrook School single form entry - will not be able to cope.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56791
Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Matthew Greene
On very busy road with some access restrictions - unsuitable for children on foot
Pedestrian access limited.
No good public transport
Adverse effect on primary schooling
Inadequate healthcare provision with likely detrimental impact on service.
Impact of a large site likely to be greater.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56919
Derbyniwyd: 28/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Mr & Mrs J Morby
Local infrastructure would not support site needs. Concerns:
effect on village quality of life; safety and security; potential effect on crime rates; effect on house prices; effect on house insurance.
Refer to issues with other sites.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56976
Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Barwood Strategic Land II Limited
Asiant : HOW Planning LLP
Strongly object. Essentially a gateway site, located in a sensitive setting and on a prominent approach to Warwick. The area is highly sensitive in terms of the setting of the Grade I Listed Park and Conservation Area.
The 31 pitches could be accommodated on a single site in a less sensitive location than this site.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56984
Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Geoff & Judy Cooper
Too close to busy main road/motorway; too noisy for occupants and distraction to drivers.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 56994
Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Mr Nigel Pugh
Concern that sites being forced on small communities unable to defend local wishes.
Very remote from main Centres.
Access on main road with no means of pedestrian access
Could place undue pressure on infrastructure and services.
School always at capacity and may not be able to provide for needs.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 57004
Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Richard Taylor-Watts
Fails to meet criteria.
Access to surgery and school only possible by car; increasing traffic and congestion.
Access onto A429 hazardous. Infrequent gaps (up to 5 mins) in 50mph+ traffic. Recent fatality.
Noise from heavily used road.
Material detrimental impact on vista and landscape views. Proximity of Warwick Castle.
Fail to promote peaceful and integrated co-existence; strong local objection.
Local infrastructure at breaking point; needs new investment including A429 junctions and local sewers and drains.
Previous landfill site requires additional validation.
Unacceptable loss of farmland and rural employment.
Site not available.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 57035
Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Sarah Taylor-Watts
Fails to meet criteria.
Access to surgery and school only possible by car; increasing traffic and congestion.
Access onto A429 hazardous. Infrequent gaps (up to 5 mins) in 50mph+ traffic. Recent fatality.
Noise from heavily used road.
Material detrimental impact on vista and landscape views. Proximity of Warwick Castle.
Fail to promote peaceful and integrated co-existence; strong local objection.
Local infrastructure at breaking point; needs new investment including A429 junctions and local sewers and drains.
Previous landfill site requires additional validation.
Unacceptable loss of farmland and rural employment.
Site not available.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 57162
Derbyniwyd: 27/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Mrs Amanda Griffin
Not sustainable in terms of multi-modal accessibility. No access to local community facilities (schools, doctors etc) on foot or bike via footpaths or cycle routes. Only accessible by car placing further pressure on highway network.
Adjacent to The Asps - should remain open as backdrop to Warwick Castle Park.
On historic landfill with potential for gas and unsuitable for habitation.
Negative impact on capacity of Barford St Peter's School.
Wild deer reported on land.
Material adverse effect on landscape and could not be integrated without harm to visual amenity.
Proposal disregards Rural Area Policies RAP1, 6, 10 and 15.
Will not allow peaceful and integrated co-existence with the local community.
Unacceptable loss of farmland and rural employment rendering isolated site totally unviable.
Access from already heavily used road network would not be safe.
Site not deliverable.
Ecological value not assessed.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 57219
Derbyniwyd: 26/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Mr Tom Hainey
Would have a significantly negative impact on capacity of Barford St Peter's School.
On historic landfill - may still be gas and unsuitable for occupation.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 57226
Derbyniwyd: 26/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Liz Hainey
Would have a significantly negative impact on capacity of Barford St Peter's School.
On historic landfill - may still be gas and unsuitable for occupation.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 57244
Derbyniwyd: 26/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Eric & Valerie Wilde
Nifer y bobl: 2
Close to residential development and contrary to peaceful and integrated co-existence.
Remote location contrary to criteria of need for convenient access to GP surgery (none in Barford), school and public transport, provision of utilities, services, waste disposal, etc..
Also at variance with avoiding locations having adverse impact on natural environment or without harm to character of area - location in rural area that will be badly affected.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 57257
Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Mr Jordan Ainslie
Does not provide local amenities.
No footpaths to reach public transport.
Farm land and previously a landfill site.
Bordered by dangerous roads.
Close to M40 creating noise/pollution for occupants.
Mobile phone mast lcoated onsite with negative health impact.
No utilities on current grazing land.
Borders historic park of Warwick Caslte and is site of ecological importance.
Borders large heronry and is site of interest for nature conservation.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 57366
Derbyniwyd: 29/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Mrs Lynda Wardle
No public transport on site.
Not near to GP surgery.
Negative impact on local schools.
Dangerous access and would increase traffic in village which is why by pass was built.
Noise from M40.
New services would need to be installed.
Back drop to Warwick Castle Park; traveller site would have adverse impact on landscape/wildlife/environment.
Previously landfill site not suitable for building.
Not a place for peaceful integration.
Business uses not allowed.
No restriction on numbers of people.
Sites at Pathlow and Shipston should be fully utilised first.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 57617
Derbyniwyd: 25/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Emma Williams
Adjoins The Asps which WDC previously concluded should remain undeveloped, particularly given the impact Warwick Castle and its park.
Site is situated on landfill.
Area supports range of wildlife whose habitat would disturbed or removed as a result.
Disregards Rural Area Policies: RAPs 1 (New Housing), 6 (New Employment), 10 (Safeguarding Rural Roads) and 15 (Camping and caravan Sites).
No access to facilities (e.g. doctors, schools etc.) thereby increasing car journeys.
Have an adverse impact on the visual aspect of picturesque countryside and farmland.
Vehicle access would be dangerous to and from the site.
Negative impact on Barford St. Peter's School which is expanding to accommodate current school children.
Site is unavailable and not deliverable.
More suitable and sustainable to identify Brownfield sites within the urban areas of Kenilworth, Warwick and Leamington.
Should meet Gypsy and Traveller requirements through proposed major new housing developments in Kenilworth, Warwick and Leamington as more suitable, sustainable and integrated.
Should review Green Belt and allow sites north of Warwick, Leamington and Kenilworth.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 57817
Derbyniwyd: 24/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Mark Williams
Adjoins The Asps which WDC previously concluded should remain undeveloped, particularly given the impact Warwick Castle and its park.
Site is situated on landfill.
Area supports range of wildlife whose habitat would disturbed or removed as a result.
Disregards Rural Area Policies: RAPs 1 (New Housing), 6 (New Employment), 10 (Safeguarding Rural Roads) and 15 (Camping and caravan Sites).
No access to facilities (e.g. doctors, schools etc.) thereby increasing car journeys.
Have an adverse impact on the visual aspect of picturesque countryside and farmland.
Vehicle access would be dangerous to and from the site.
Negative impact on Barford St. Peter's School which is expanding to accommodate current school children.
Site is unavailable and not deliverable.
More suitable and sustainable to identify Brownfield sites within the urban areas of Kenilworth, Warwick and Leamington.
Should meet Gypsy and Traveller requirements through proposed major new housing developments in Kenilworth, Warwick and Leamington as more suitable, sustainable and integrated.
Should review Green Belt and allow sites north of Warwick, Leamington and Kenilworth.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 57989
Derbyniwyd: 22/07/2013
Ymatebydd: D S and A J Warren and Beasley
Nifer y bobl: 2
Site is situated on landfill.
Adjoins The Asps which WDC previously concluded should remain undeveloped, particularly given the impact Warwick Castle and its park.
Area supports range of wildlife whose habitat would disturbed or removed as a result.
Unsafe access and egress via busy main road.
Poor access to local community facilities (schools, doctors surgeries etc) on foot, bike or by bus. Will increase car journeys which is unsustainable.
Disregards Rural Area Policies: RAPs 1 (New Housing), 6 (New Employment), 10 (Safeguarding Rural Roads) and 15 (Camping and caravan Sites).
Unacceptable loss of farmland and rural employment.
Material negative impact on Barford St. Peter's School, especially given 70-90 new dwellings proposed for the village.
Material adverse effect on landscape harming visual amenity of the site.
Location doesn't allow for peaceful and integrated co-existence with the local community.
Unavailable and so not deliverable.
Gwrthwynebu
Gypsy and Traveller Site Options
ID sylw: 58063
Derbyniwyd: 23/07/2013
Ymatebydd: Niki & Jason Tolley
Impact on local schools will be an issue. Barford St Peters is an already over subscribed SMALL village school. It has already been indicated in the local plan that more housing in the area will be built. The school will not cope with increase in numbers of pupils.
wild deer inhabiting land. This should be considered
very close to proposed building within local plan, road networks will struggle
Loss of farmland impacting on local rural businesses and employment
these areas are not close to local communities and do not allow ' peaceful and integrated co-existence with the local community'
Access by vehicles will be difficult and dangerous - a potential safety issue.
Site does not have access to local amenities such as doctors surgeries, schools etc. People would need to use a vehicle which adds more pressure to roads and impact on environment.