BASE HEADER
Map 1
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67503
Derbyniwyd: 26/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Linda Green
The infrastructure will not accommodate this level of community who will put additional burden on local service i.e. doctors, hospital, education etc. especially with the plans for additional housing proposed. Also the road network, risk to historic buildings and air pollution.
They do not want to be part of the community. The pitches require too much land.
Impact on tourism/businesses
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67504
Derbyniwyd: 10/12/2014
Ymatebydd: David Dorsett
The site is next to a major sewerage works which can be smelt from almost a mile away on some days. This would be so unpleasant for the gypsy community and is surely unhygienic especially for their children.
The site is surrounded by the M40, the River Avon and the sewerage works, how does this constitute a safe environment?
It requires a a significant amount of screening/protection from the main tourist route into Historic Warwick, the M40, the River Avon and the Severn Trent sewage works. As it is currently agricultural land it will also require hard surfacing works and connection to utilities.
It is in a flood zone and so requires flood risk mitigation with all associated costs.
The existing access roads will require improvement to ensure suitability.
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67505
Derbyniwyd: 10/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Sharon Dorset
The site is next to a major sewerage works which can be smelt from almost a mile away on some days. This would be so unpleasant for the gypsy community and is surely unhygienic especially for their children. The site is surrounded by the M40, the River Avon and the sewerage works, how does this constitute a safe environment?
It requires a a significant amount of screening/protection from the main tourist route into Historic Warwick, the M40, the River Avon and the Severn Trent sewage works. As it is currently agricultural land it will also require hard surfacing works and connection to utilities.
It is in a flood zone and so requires flood risk mitigation with all associated costs.
The existing access roads will require improvement to ensure suitability.
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67506
Derbyniwyd: 26/11/2014
Ymatebydd: Mr & Miss Julian & Samantha Watson & Millership
The site is not in keeping with the surrounding area and will cause a loss of visual amenity, will cause noise and disturbance from its access, occupation and use
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67507
Derbyniwyd: 26/11/2014
Ymatebydd: A & C Williams
Previous experience of Traveller sites
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67508
Derbyniwyd: 09/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Mrs Gillian Duggan
Consultation has been wholly inadequate with no WDC representative at a public meeting.
The site is within reasonable distance of local facilities but these are highly pressurised, in particular the schools and medical facilities
Site is near the road network but this is heavily congested close to a motorway junction. Access road to Severn Trent may not be available which will mean considerable investment in infrastructure.
Site is too large, impacting in terms of dominance on the local environs.
Flood risk, water pollution, air quality and noise pollution - inappropriate for Council to divert funds for this.
Screening would require significant investment.
Negative impact on the economy and tourism of Warwick. To site around 50% of required pitches on one site is not consistent with the aims of not letting these sites dominate. Sites should be more widely spread across the county.
Sylw
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67509
Derbyniwyd: 27/11/2014
Ymatebydd: Historic England
The secondary/indirect impact of the proposal should be considered. For example could the 'rural' character of the lane serving the site, and the Grade II* Longbridge Manor, be retained as a consequence? Are intrusive highway works to facilitate the development required? How might these issues be addressed?
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67510
Derbyniwyd: 08/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Mrs Cathryn Armer
Unfeasible, unlawful and not suitable or viable
Lack of due process. Site did not appear in original list or at shortlisting
Lack of clear information. Process flawed and not within spirit of democracy
Site is next to sewage works with accompanying smells
On the other side is the M40 the full impact of which has not been fully evaluated
Air pollution/noise pollution
Significant risks and hazards in this location
Neither suitable nor viable
Flood plain - costs of mitigation
Impact on traffic. Access issues onto A429 and to the site. STW will not give access over their land. Track is not wide enough for vehicles to pass or for emergency vehicles
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67514
Derbyniwyd: 27/11/2014
Ymatebydd: Warwick Town Council
Local residents do not support the proposal and no doubt those residents have written expressing the reasons for their objection.
The Town Council considers that this site is not appropriate for residential use
Had the land been considered appropriate for residential use then the question arises why it was not included for the purpose in the Draft Local Plan.
Severn Trent Water has given advice on the extension of the cordon sanitaire around the sewage works, but in planning terms is it acceptable to site residential development so near to sewage works? It could be intolerable for residents within or outside their homes.
Furthermore residents would also be subject to high levels of noise from the M40 and residents living in mobile homes with limited noise insulation, would suffer even more than residents in conventional housing.
The Town Council also considers that the proximity of the river and the inclusion of the land within the flood plain is reason for the development not to take place. Even if compensatory works can be carried it is poor planning practice to knowingly locate development in the flood plain, for even if this land is fully protected, flooding will be transferred elsewhere.
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67515
Derbyniwyd: 27/11/2014
Ymatebydd: Mr Richard Clark
There was not a single site in the consultation in and around Kenilworth and I yet can't believe there wasn't a single brown field/ prev. industrial site that would be suitable
Out of nowhere a site taking a large percentage of the pitches is proposed again in SW Warwick.
There has been zero formal public consultation on this proposed site other than two hastily arranged drop in's, which were at the most inappropriate times for working families.
No public meeting was arranged and then refusing to attend one arranged by the residents association.
Barford sites seemed to be rejected in haste.
The site selected is totally inappropriate on the main tourist route
G&T community themselves ask for smaller sites not big sites as they recognise these larger sites cause issues, and friction with the community.
Newburgh school is at maximum capacity.
Not consulted with any of local business. Tournament Fields still has more land for sale.
Proximity to wildlife areas and the proximity to the River Avon.
Would families want to live in such proximity to the M40 for noise and danger to children or the ST Sewage plant that produces smells.
Local opinion is against it and therefore wholly unlikely to achieve social integration.
There should be a formal and due period of consultation allowing the tax paying and voting public to have their say.
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67516
Derbyniwyd: 08/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Mr John Houston
Site is going to be situated near the river, and M40 motorway with access being via a small farm road, which is unsuitable for vehicles up to 25 meters long. Severn Trent Water have not been contacted, fully oppose the site, and have denied access to the site via the original suggested route. This restricts the access to the proposed site via a small farm track road leading from Longbridge and from the M40 roundabout exit. This route has already been the scene of many accidents. Stratford Road is already a congested route. Additional slow moving and heavy vehicles using this route and trying to turn into the farm road, will cause further complication and congestion.
Site is in a designated flood plain.
The proposed size of the site is itself a serious concern as it would be an expensive option to build a site of this size. I want to understand who is funding the site. If it flooded, who would pay for any damage repairs to the site Being so close to the M40 and the river also makes this site a dangerous and hazardous area for children. Being so close to the treatment works, the smell would be intolerable. How it would be possible to put a site and people this close to a treatment plant which must be against health and safety hygiene levels.
There is a current lack of interest in the area for businesses. The proposal, would do nothing more than further reduce the chances of businesses location the current business park.
There has not been consultation with the builders of new residential properties adjacent. Should the proposed site have been made public knowledge earlier, many residents would not have purchased. WDC has now decided to try to rail road this new proposed site through.
There has been significant lack of consultation with local residents and businesses. This is extremely unfair and unacceptable.
The impact on the saleable value of recently purchased residential homes will be seriously adversely affected
The impact on the local doctors surgery, the local schools and other facilities as well as small local business will also be adversely impact should this go ahead
Disappointed and disgusted that WDC declined to attend public meeting.
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67517
Derbyniwyd: 08/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Rebecca Mitchell
The road is already exceedingly congested and the area would certainly not be suitable for the large vehicles that would be using the site.
More thought needs to go into the location of proposed sites in view of roads, infrastructure, school places and GP surgeries.
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67518
Derbyniwyd: 27/11/2014
Ymatebydd: Mr & Miss Paul & Kim Jones & Hensey
The site will be an eyesore on a very important route into Warwick which heavily depends on leisure and tourism.
Why would Travellers want to live next to a sewerage treatment works and river
Existing and potential businesses would surely be opposed
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67519
Derbyniwyd: 09/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Mr Barrie Duggan
Negative impact on economy and tourism.
Consultation process has been wholly inadequate. Little information has been provided proactively and WDC representatives did not attend public meeting.
Site may be within reasonable distance of local facilities but these are heavily pressured, particularly in terms of schools and medical facilities.
Site may be near a major road network but it is congested and the access will require investment.
Size of the site is too large in terms on dominance in local environs.
Investment needed in infrastructure because of flood risk, water pollution, air quality and noise pollution.
Residents of Warwick have not been listened to.
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67520
Derbyniwyd: 09/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Mr M Daniels
A key objective of the council is to ensure that scarce public funds are spent wisely, yet little evidence of the costs of making the proposed site suitable for habitation have been made available. CPO would be expensive and may prove fruitless for the Council.
Located in the flood plain, which is likely to add to the costs of preparing the site. Commercial viability of the site called into question
Second objective of the council is to support local business and to ensure a thriving. The proposal looks likely to have a detrimental impact. The proximity to the Tournament Fields business park and local hotels is out of keeping and will not encourage businesses to locate their offices in the area. May also deter future developers from seeking to build additional housing in the area.
May damage the town's image as a key tourist destination.
It is the duty of the council to provide a decent standard of accommodation to all the people it looks to locate. Locating families next to a sewage works, in a flood plain and next to a busy road does not to meet the basic minimum standards one would expect.
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67521
Derbyniwyd: 09/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Liz Rogers-Mills
Impact on tourism.
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67522
Derbyniwyd: 09/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Julie Richardson
Impact a site such as this will have on the local economy. Warwick is a striving tourist town and of particular historic interest and therefore attracts a huge amount of tourism which in supports our local economy. Business park opposite this proposed site - although this is filling up there is potential for more businesses - they are unlikely to consider this site with a gypsy/traveller site in close proximity.
Is the site a 'safe environment' ? Government's guidelines state sites should not be located near hazardous places, as this will obviously have a detrimental effect on general health and well-being of residents - with particular risks for young children.
Can't consider a site where there is risk of flooding, especially where there may be children living?
Access to the site is totally unsuitable - certainly not enough space to allow two vehicles to pass and located on a very busy and dangerous bend
Why wasn't this site part of the original consultation?
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67523
Derbyniwyd: 28/11/2014
Ymatebydd: Mr & Mrs Nigel & Lisa Vasey
The Chase Meadow estate has good schools, close links to all Motorway networks for business/work travel, the feel of a community spirit and a comfortable general standard of living everyone seems to adhere to on the estate. At no point was there any mention of Chase Meadow ever being near a proposed Gypsy Traveller site.Why should Gypsy Travellers get the same privileges and not pay any of their taxes?
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67524
Derbyniwyd: 28/11/2014
Ymatebydd: Mr Paul Finch
Threat of anti-social behaviour and crime
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67525
Derbyniwyd: 28/11/2014
Ymatebydd: Miss Abby Finch
Increase in anti-social behaviour and crime
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67526
Derbyniwyd: 28/11/2014
Ymatebydd: Mr & Mrs Paul & Rachel Abdy
Warwick an unsuitable place for a Gypsy site
Impact on tourism
Impact on businesses
Safety issues
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67527
Derbyniwyd: 29/11/2014
Ymatebydd: Mr & Mrs Ben & Helen Quaintance
Infrastructure cannot cope with more traffic and more people needing healthcare and schools.
Gypsy and Traveller site would not be in keeping and would be too close to existing businesses and residential areas
First impression of town would be damaged
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67528
Derbyniwyd: 09/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Mrs Christine Thomas
Access not clearly defined.
Site is near to sewage works from which smells are strong. Motorway is load and heavily used - not conducive for children with air water and soil quality issues within the boundaries
Within flood plain.
Area is ripe for commercial development which could be affected by this proposal.
Short consultation time has made it difficult to have clear consultation process
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67529
Derbyniwyd: 09/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Mr Ray Bradshaw
The Council's Consultation document does not give details of access to the site.
The farm track is only a single track with short areas to pass small vehicles. It is unsuitable for heavy usage as it is not hard surfaced and needs regular maintenance.
It is difficult turning right off the Stratford Road on a blind bend with longer views obscured by trees and shrubs. Slow moving, turning vehicles with long trailers would be a serious extra hazard at this accident black spot.
The site was partially flooded during the 1998 floods. This would be a grave risk for people in single storey dwellings. The flood plain on the other river side to the proposed site was totally submerged.
The 15 pitch site is the maximum size for a gypsy and traveller site. This site will completely overwhelm the three dwellings immediately next to it and the village of Longbridge. It is therefore unsuitable.
It is not clear who will bear the set up costs for the site which will be considerable and could cost the local council a lot of money that it can ill afford in these times of austerity.
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67530
Derbyniwyd: 09/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Dr Adam Parker
Air, water and soil quality: SA identified this as area of significant concern so close to sewage works and a busy motorway. The resultant noise, air and soil pollution suggest that this is not a suitable location.
Flooding: area is a designated floodplain within zones 2 and 3 indicating that the area is highly susceptible to flooding.
Access: access will be via a narrow farm track, totally unsuitable for a number of reasons - (i) it does not provide easy access for emergency vehicles; (ii) it does not allow two vehicles to pass and (iii) the location of the junction with the Stratford Road, means that the increased volume of long vehicles turning will introduce significant health and safety risks. This junction is already a known blackspot
Effect on the local economy: Tournament Fields is proposed to be the premier office location in Warwick with potential to attract a significant number of jobs. Any plan that is highly likely to have a significant detrimental effect on the saleability of this land is also likely to significantly reduce the number of jobs being introduced
Disgusted nobody from Warwick District Council accepted the offer to attend the public meeting at Aylesford School
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67531
Derbyniwyd: 30/11/2014
Ymatebydd: Mr John Cooknell
The proposed vehicular access to the site is not good, there is insufficient detail given to assess whether there are safe facilities for pedestrians and cyclists, both during the construction of the site and when the site is occupied and in use.
The proposed vehicular access will cross National Cycle Network Route 41. WCC are yet to comment on safety of vehicular/pedestrian/cyclists access.
This route is heavily used by cyclists using the adjacent pedestrian/cyclists bridge over the M40, and adequate means of access and safe access to the bridge will need to be maintained.
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67532
Derbyniwyd: 08/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Mrs Carly Gold
The road noise (from the M40 & A46) is a significant problem. The proposed land is in close proximity to these roads and a sewage works. The associated noise and air pollution, particularly on a site where children will be living, should cause significant apprehension. I believe the health and safety of prospective residents will be at risk.
The site is in flood zones 2 and 3. Caravans are considered "highly vulnerable" and should not be permitted in areas where there is a high probability that flooding will occur. Need evidence to show this can be overcome
The Council's Consultation document fails to address the issue of access. Assume that the current narrow farm track leading to the site from Longbridge would be proposed. This track would be totally unsuitable. In addition, accessing the site from Longbridge would place the main entrance to the site next to a Grade 2 listed Longbridge Manor and on a dangerous bend in the road with poor visibility.
The cost of improving access, migrating flood risk, air, noise & soil pollution renders the plans un-deliverable.
SA states the effect on the economy is 'uncertain at this stage'. Furthermore the consultation documentation makes no reference to the potential effect of the site on the local economy and Tournament Fields in particular.
Whilst I fully applaud the local council's efforts to fulfill a legitimate need for residence for the travelling community, 'dumping' them on a site that is totally unsuitable because they have failed to find any other sites is not acceptable.
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67533
Derbyniwyd: 01/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Mr Graham Hatch
The GP surgery will require additional funding to cope with extra demand.
Budbrooke School is already in special measures and the inclusion of traveller children will cause further disruption. Other local schools have very few places available. There is inadequate local infrastructure in place.
The current narrow farm track leading to the proposed site from Longbridge is totally inadequate as a means of access.
The suggested site allows for the siting of 15 pitches with associated access road and open space. The additional open space mentioned means the use of such a vast area provides potential for further illegal encampments. Occupancy on the pitches cannot be regulated or controlled. There is a concern if the site is approved for a given number of pitches, the gypsy & travelling community will breach planning policy
In addition, there is a potential risk an overflow of gypsies and travellers from the allocated 15 pitches may migrate to Chase Meadow and surrounding areas resulting in antisocial behaviour
Planning application for housing on this site
Air, Water and Soil Quality are not suitable where children will live.
The environmental noise assessment states the noise in decibels exceeds 80 for prolonged periods. There is a potential for damage to the resident's hearing, making the site unsuitable.
The site is on a designated flood plain within flood zones 2 and 3. Caravans are considered "highly vulnerable" and should not be permitted in such areas
The SA states that 'the effect on the economy is uncertain at this stage'. The Consultation Documentation makes no mention of the potential effect of the site on the local economy
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67536
Derbyniwyd: 09/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Miss Stephanie Lines
Effect on house prices and saleability issues
Access is on busy road and this would increase traffic.
Area is in flood plain. How much will it cost to prevent this being an issue.
Gwrthwynebu
Preferred Options Consultation - Land at Stratford Road, Warwick
ID sylw: 67537
Derbyniwyd: 08/12/2014
Ymatebydd: Mrs Tabitha Duckhouse
Access to the site is not at all suitable for the sort of vehicles that will be using the narrow farm track on a regular basis.
The road from the A429 that leads to the Longbridge Village is unsuitable for the size of vehicles and an accident black spot. Long, slow vehicles will be leaving that road junction to join traffic that is already travelling at 40mph. I deem this to be totally inappropriate & makes it dangerous for all road users. This is an unnecessary & unacceptable risk for the current local residents.
the amount of hard standing that is proposed this will have a significant negative impact on local wildlife, as well as the management of the water in the area. The proposed site I believe is also on a flood plain and caravans are vulnerable. Flood alleviation schemes are expensive and often fail to deliver.
The proposed development will dominate and overshadow the existing Longbridge village.
Impact on tourism and local economy.
Facilities are stretched - GP surgery, Warwick Hospital and schools will place greater burden on Council funds
Consultation leaves a lot to be desired. This site was not on the original list. Council railroading decision making