BASE HEADER

PO1: Preferred Level of Growth

Yn dangos sylwadau a ffurflenni 91 i 120 o 411

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49181

Derbyniwyd: 26/07/2012

Ymatebydd: The Sundial Group and Gleeson Developments

Nifer y bobl: 2

Asiant : Savills (L&P) Ltd

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

NPPF requires LPAs to boost significantly the supply of housing.The 10,800 dwellings figure set out at PO1 does not meet the need for housing. The SHMA suggests 14,300 are required between 2011 and 2031. It also does provide for affordable housing.
To make the Local Plan sound it must be in conformity with the NPPF. PO1 does not meet the full, objectively assessed needs for market or affordable housing in the District and is therefore, unsound.

The Plan period should be 20 years "to take account of longer term requirements" (NPPF)

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49209

Derbyniwyd: 20/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Helen Franklin

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Where do figures come from for 10,800 houses?
It is in interest of WDC to have as many new houses as possible, as they receive 6 times Council Tax from New Homes Bonus Scheme for every dwelling completed and more if affordable housing? Plan not led by suitability but interest of landowners to sell off land for housing. Not sufficient grounds for massive increase in population concentrated in small area as plans make little use of rural area development. Villages need regenerating. Radford Semele has had no growth since 1960s and has a school, good transport links to M40, Fosse Way and Leamington Station and WHITE FIELD. If such large number needed, they should be South Leamington on white field sites as Leamington has all amenities.
This is WDC plan not Kenilworth plan and there are other places where housing could be built.

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49214

Derbyniwyd: 24/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Hallam Land Management & William Davies Ltd

Asiant : Marrons

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The Relationship between Housing and Employment Growth
i.Summary of the projections used to inform Policy PO1 is set out at Figures
2.21 and 2.22 of the Strategic Housing Market Assessment (March 2012)
(SHMA). Three of the thirteen (13) projections set out in the SHMA are
summarised in Table 5.1 of the Plan. Each of these are at the upper end of the
range that can be identified from the thirteen projections, which extend from
191 dwellings per annum (PROJ6) to 800 dwellings per annum (PRJOJ13).
ii. The three projections "considered to be worthy of further consideration" and
as referred to in Table 5.1 are as follows:
Projection 1. (PROJ1 of Fig 2.21/22.) Trend based and assuming continued
in migration of 400 persons per annum. The resulting housing requirement is
596 dwellings per annum or 11,921 dwellings 2011 - 2031.
Projection 2. (PROJ7 of Fig 2.21/22.) Projected employment growth of
11,860 jobs. Within this projection migration levels are adjusted so that the
growth in the labour supply matches the growth in the demand for labour
(jobs). The resulting housing requirement is 716 dwellings per annum or
14,310 dwellings 2011 - 2031. The demand for new housing could be
adjusted downwards by increasing levels of in-commuting.
Projection 3. (PROJ8 of Fig 2.21/22.) Projected labour force growth derived
from a population growth of 17,070 persons. Taking account of existing
commuting dynamics, this results in a growth in jobs of 7,895 jobs. The
resulting housing requirement is 569 dwellings per annum or 11,376 dwellings
2011 - 2031.
iii. Projection 3 is not considered appropriate, because the increase in jobs
(11,860 see Projection 2) is not matched by an increase in homes. Projections
1 and 2 were considered the more appropriate basis for estimating growth in
the District.
iv. Policy PO1, however, is based on the provision of 600 homes per annum. To
balance homes and jobs would require 716 homes per annum. In order to
support the forecast of 11,860 jobs there will need to be an increase in incommuting
to the District from adjoining areas to provide the necessary labour
force.
v. If the housing policy remains at 600 dwellings per annum, then the economic
growth of the District will require the provision of some additional homes
(about 116 dwellings per annum, i.e. 716 - 600 = 116), in those Districts,
which presently show commuter flows into Warwick.
b. Evidence of the Co-operation with Neighbouring Authorities
(i) If the broad strategic objectives of the plan are to "facilitate the growth and
development of the local economy" (see para 2.5), maintain high levels of
employment and to balance housing growth with employment growth, then the
plan should make provision for the development of 716 dwellings per annum
or 12,888 dwellings over the plan period 2011 - 2029. Development at this
scale would not be reliant on adjoining authorities acting as "hosts" to growing
numbers of in-commuters to the District over the plan period so that the
growth I employment opportunities can be realised.
(ii) In the alternative, should the Local Plan be progressed on the basis of
providing 600 new homes per annum or 10,800 dwellings over the plan period,
then some of the housing to "match the growth in employment", will be
provided outside the District. However, that assumption must be supported by
evidence to indicate that the local authorities who "host" the anticipated
growth in the number of in-commuters to Warwick are content to provide land
for the necessary number of new homes. For the plan to be sound and in
conformity with the advice in the NPPF at paragraphs 178 - 181 it cannot be
appropriate to rely on the intention set out in paragraph 5.12 of the plan, which
states that:
"The Council will, however, be consulting neighbouring
authorities on its proposals."
For the plans proposals to move forward on the basis of completing 600
dwellings per annum it must demonstrate how and where some 116 homes per
annum (716 - 600) are to be constructed. It will be wholly inappropriate to
progress the plan to submission stage without evidence that this issue has been
resolved on the basis of an agreement at sub-regional level.
(iii) Notwithstanding the observation at (ii) above, Policy PO3 and Tables 7.1 and
7.2 note that the plan will provide for "allocations" totalling 8,360 dwellings;
some 1,374 dwellings or 76 dwellings per annum more than the required scale
of new housing to be provided on allocated sites (see Table 7.1). These
planned allocations together with the addition of some further suitable SHLAA
sites could, in our view, meet the higher level of provision required to achieve
the balance between housing and employment.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49215

Derbyniwyd: 23/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Mr Nigel Hamilton

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Not sustainable level of growth.
Level of infrastructure does not match population growth forecast.
40% increase in population over 15 years is unsustainable and will cause damage to character of Warwick County town.
Population growth has been due to immigration which government wishes to reduce so why planning for even greater level of growth than previously experienced.
Housing demand growth is from combination of net immigration/changes in household demographics towards smaller households.
Impact of prolonged recession which government says could last another decade, will impact on ability to afford housing.
Rising age of first time buyers and profound demographic change since 2008 in more young adults living with parents .
Plan assuming rapid increase in demand for single occupancy
households; demographic trend away from this?
Is modelling based on current data, or looking at demand during rapid growth/easy availability of mortgage loans pre 2008 crash?
Could mean far less individual units required but greater emphasis given for multi generational living , with
semi independent adults?

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49350

Derbyniwyd: 04/08/2012

Ymatebydd: Robert Ashby

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The claimed need for 10,800 new houses is not supported in the Plan and applies only to the period of the Plan. The next "Plan" is likely to want another 10,000 - and then another. It really means "another 500/600 extra houses a year" every year without end.

The option of no more growth should e considered so that we avoid creeping urbanisation to the detriment of our towns which are already struggling to cope.

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49357

Derbyniwyd: 08/08/2012

Ymatebydd: Commercial Estate Group and the McGregor Family

Nifer y bobl: 2

Asiant : Broadway Malyan

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Promoting sustainable economic growth is a key priority for the planning system. The NPPF has a clear presumption in favour of sustainable development and seeks to boost significantly the supply of housing - requiring LPAs to meet full, objectively assessed needs. NPPF has a similar stance in relation to business needs. PO1 housing growth figure is too low. It should be based on employment growth and should seek to reduce in-commting to reduce travel to work. Growth needs to go beyond the 715pa set out in the SHMA and the employment led figure. Total of 14,400 homes should be provided

Cefnogi

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49372

Derbyniwyd: 13/08/2012

Ymatebydd: Coventry & Warwickshire Local Enterprise Partnership

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Notes the decision to choose the option 1 level of growth (600 pa 2011 to 2029)and the difficulties in proposing greenfield and greenbelt development but it has to be recognised that WDC has less than 3 years housing supply and effort must be taken to increase supply.

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49474

Derbyniwyd: 26/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Mr. A. Burrows

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The WDC Housing needs assessment and inward migration figures appear incorrect, the arguments are flawed and the assumptions false. The Council should consider work undertaken by Bishops Tachbrook, which uses newly published census data. A more realistic conclusion is arrived at - only 5,336 houses needed over the plan period.

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49508

Derbyniwyd: 06/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Georgina Wilson

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Projections made during strong economic period.
This kind of growth unlikely to be as predicted.
Many unsold flats already again suggesting need for less new homes.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49554

Derbyniwyd: 16/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Leek Wootton & Guy's Cliffe Parish Council

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

We believe that the basis upon which projections of future population and housing needs are not realistic or supported by proven evidence, and that the housing development plans for Warwick District should be much smaller than those proposed.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49610

Derbyniwyd: 19/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Mrs Susan Munday

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Where do figures come from? Based on new homes bonus gain?
Led by suitablity for land owners selling off their land for housing.
Not sufficeint grounds for massive increase in population. Lots of villages need regenerating. Radford Semele has had no growth since 1960s and there is a school, it has good transport, links to M40, Fosse Way and Leamington Rail Station and in in white field zone. South of Leamingotn more suitable area.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49655

Derbyniwyd: 31/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Mr Michael Kelsey

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Housing numbers do not stack up - the model used was outdated and most of all, the input data was flawed being based on earlier projections which are no longer valid, resulting in a very considerable overestimate of housing need. No allowance appeared to have been made for the recent changes in the nature of the local work force from manual to blue and white collar and a very significant increase in numbers of professionals and academics. A detailed audit is required which considers the total availability of various types of land development options.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49668

Derbyniwyd: 17/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Martin & Kim Drew & Barnes

Nifer y bobl: 2

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Question the need to build 555 houses per years from 2014 -2029. The ONS and economic projections based on historical growth rates do not take into account the envisaged stagnation in economic growth throughout the UK for the foreseeable future plus the negative growth effects of an ageing demographic. Apart from Jaguar Landrover at Gaydon most of the envisaged commercial expansion is planned for the Gateway area around Baginton/Ryton. This would entail commuting again from South of the Rivers to the North, further compounding traffic problems over the aforementioned bridges. Therefore it would be better to build more housing nearer the Gateway Area

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49672

Derbyniwyd: 25/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Mrs E Brown

Asiant : Stansgate Planning

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Evidence from projections of employment growth published in 2010 forecast an increase of 11,860 jobs in the District betweeen 2011 and 2031. This would require an additional 715 new homes per annum. The Preferred Option housing growth figure of 600 dwellings per annum, based on the projection of past trends in the SHMA, would support an increase in jobs of 8,250. If sufficient homes are not provided to meet employment growth, employees will have to commute long distances or pay high prices for homes. Alternatively, companies may chose not to locate to the area.

The SHLAA shows that there is sfficient land to accommodate 13,400 new homes by 2029. There are additional sites available for housing, over and above those in the SHLAA.

Providing a high level of housing is the only way to meet the considerable need for affordable housing.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49673

Derbyniwyd: 25/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Mrs Lynn Hunt

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

In general support the principles and objectives relating to the amounbt of housing as the population is likely to grow and affordable housing needs to be addressed.

However the level of growth needs to be balanced against enviornmental considerations and in this context the level is too high and cannot be accommodated without significant environmental impacts. It is also questioned whether this level of growth is needed given current economic circumstances and the state of housing market.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49683

Derbyniwyd: 27/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Barford, Sherbourne and Wasperton Joint Parish Council

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The proposed level of housing growth of 555 homes per year is not supported by all the evidence available.
The baseline population on which the future need is calculated on the ONS estimate of 138,670. Since those calculations the 2011 census has measured it at 136,000. The initial stage of consultation gave a range of growth possibilities and the clear majority of respondents opted for the lower growth levels. Residents made a clear choice to accept lower infrastructure gains in return for limiting growth and specifically avoiding more growth in excess of local need. Approximately 250 homes per year would appear to be more than adequate to meet these needs.

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49736

Derbyniwyd: 27/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Parichial Church Council Of St James Church

Nifer y bobl: 2

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The quantity of housing proposed is not soundly based and seems to only relate to what the Government are likely to find acceptable when the plan is submitted. Properly assessing the numbers is vital, clearly setting out the thinking behind a sustainable increase for the local area.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49743

Derbyniwyd: 24/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Mr R. J. Howes

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Population projections may be flawed since they assume a continuation of recent exceptionally high rates of growth. This could be a false assumption.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49753

Derbyniwyd: 25/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Sir Thomas White Charity

Asiant : Stansgate Planning

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Evidence from projections of employment growth published in 2010 forecast an increase of 11,860 jobs in the District betweeen 2011 and 2031. This would require an additional 715 new homes per annum. The Preferred Option housing growth figure of 600 dwellings per annum, based on the projection of past trends in the SHMA, would support an increase in jobs of 8,250. If sufficient homes are not provided to meet employment growth, employees will have to commute long distances or pay high prices for homes. Alternatively, companies may chose not to locate to the area.

The SHLAA shows that there is sfficient land to accommodate 13,400 new homes by 2029. There are additional sites available for housing, over and above those in the SHLAA.

Providing a high level of housing is the only way to meet the considerable need for affordable housing.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49765

Derbyniwyd: 03/08/2012

Ymatebydd: Gallagher Estates

Asiant : Pegasus Group

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The preferred level of growth (10,800) fails to accord with the requirements of NPPF. A Strategic Housing Market Assessment should have been carried out for a larger Housing Market Area with adjoining authorities.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49787

Derbyniwyd: 24/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Linda & John Simpson

Nifer y bobl: 2

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The level of growth proposed has not been justified as they are based on a particular period whih may not be accurately representative.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49792

Derbyniwyd: 23/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Chris Bowden

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Having regard to the current economic situation it is unlikely the the projection for the number of new houses required is correct and I believe the proposed number is over stated

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49800

Derbyniwyd: 24/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Drs Mandy Barnett & Patrick James

Nifer y bobl: 2

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Key points have been missed in arriving at the proposed number of houses. The projected figures are based on years when population expansion has been exceptional. Economic circumstances suggest this will not continue.

The figures do not distinguish between houses and households. The population is not growing substantially in terms of young families whilst elderly two or single person households are expected to rise. Elderly people require apartments or smaller houses with easy access to shops. This is unlikely to be achieved through the proposed urban expansions.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49828

Derbyniwyd: 23/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Dan Robbins

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

ONS figures show the level of growth will slow down and on average will be 0.73%p.a. and 11% increase over 15 years - 16,000 people. For 10,800 houses that works out at less than 1.5 people per unit which seems low and is unjustifiable if you limit the age range to those likely to buy a property.

The actual requirement seems to be less than half that proposed.

There is already a surplus of housing with property available at Chase Meadow, Portobello and Leamington Station. Why is there a need for more in this context, particularly with the economic climate as it is?

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49841

Derbyniwyd: 02/08/2012

Ymatebydd: Bishops Tachbrook Parish Council

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

The Parish Council considers that the proposed level of housing growth of 555 homes per year is not supported by all the evidence available and that the evidence used is insufficiently analysed when predicting the number of homes needed. The baseline population on which the future need is calculated is over-estimated. The plan is not sound on the current information. The Parish council finds that, taking into account all the evidence including the 2011 census, 5,336 homes will be required in the plan period, which is equivalent to 254 homes per year.

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49935

Derbyniwyd: 02/08/2012

Ymatebydd: Barwood

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

We would suggest that the Council allows the market and the development industry to regulate itself in respect of the phasing and the timing of the delivery of development.
To allow the larger allocations to make a start earlier in the plan period will ensure steady delivery of housing over the life of the plan. It is not in a developer's own interest to saturate the market however steady delivery on a number of sites over a number of years will promote healthy competition and ensure sufficient time to allow such sites to be built out in full.

In addition, we highlight that the NPPF makes reference to development which is sustainable going ahead without delay. It follows that in order for a site to have secured
an allocation in what will be an adopted Local Plan, that site must be sustainable and therefore in accordance with the NPPF, there is no need for that site to be held back by
an arbitrary phasing policy.

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 49988

Derbyniwyd: 23/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Mr J Wright MP

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

In favour of LAs setting own housing requirements and calculating future housing demand but crucial that assumptions and calculations are set out with clarity. Public must have confidence in conclusions before a sensible and inclusive discussion can be entered into location of new housing.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 50016

Derbyniwyd: 26/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Mr Barry Lovekin

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Support development which provides affordable homes for younger people and improves infrastructure. However the scale of growth proposed will over-urbanise this town and create safety issues for traffic and will remove valued green belt - counter to other objectives in the Plan.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 50023

Derbyniwyd: 03/08/2012

Ymatebydd: Mr Edward Walpole-Brown

Asiant : Brown and Co

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

For a sustainable plan there should be a balance of homes and jobs. Table 5.2 confirms that the employment growth projected requires the delivery of 716 dwellings per year. If this higher level of housing development is not provided, this will mean that 2088 homes will need to be built in neighbouring districts, which is not a robust basis on which to promote the plan. Added to the 10800 homes already proposed this would give a requirement for 12900 dwellings or 717 dwellings per year. Taking off commitments, SHLAA sites and windfall sites this would leave a requirement for 9086 new dellings. Applying the council's 20% flexibility allowance this would produce a requirement to find 10,903 further housing plots.

Atodiadau:

Gwrthwynebu

Preferred Options

ID sylw: 50060

Derbyniwyd: 27/07/2012

Ymatebydd: Ms Helen Tomlinson

Crynodeb o'r Gynrychiolaeth:

Question whether the assumptions about population growth, migration and the economy are correct. If we are short of housing, why are existing developments (eg Portbello Way) not being completed?

Atodiadau: